Elizabeth Searle Unravels the Mystery of Terrorists and Teenagers in Suburban America

By Josie E. Davis

Imagine your 15 year old son, well behaved but departing – perhaps faster than you expect – into his years of teen rebellion.  Now imagine yourself.  Full time mother and wife, part-time teacher and dedicated member of the local PTA.  Dedicated, as Elizabeth Searle explores in her latest novel, to protecting.

Based on a true story (see video), Girl Held In Home is a thrilling reflection of post 9/11 suburban America, capturing the small encounters which make every day life appear inconsequential. The fourth and most recent novel published by author Elizabeth Searle, the story trails two families and one young girl held hostage in the basement of the neighborhood Muslim “terrorist cell,” as lives are quickly entwined in the days following September 11 with the desire to break free from familial obligation.

What I love about this book is the conviction of Searle’s leading narrators, Maura and Joezy, to achieve their goals.  Searle doesn’t guarantee her characters all they are after, but she offers the reader the same promise she gives her characters – hope. “I did what I could; I’ll do what I can; I did what I could,” remarks Joezy, Searle’s asthma struck super-hero smitten coming of age teen, reflecting upon his own insurmountable attempt at rescuing – and protecting – the one he loves.

“We are all hostages, and we are all terrorists,” writes Jean Boudrillard in the aftermath of 9/11 just a decade ago.  This dichotomy is what Searle uncovers, as Maura, dedicated mother and teacher, catches herself in the midst of a stumbling marriage and the affections of another woman.  “Mara,” Searle writes, is the new love of Frannie, the lesbian PTA mom, who embraces Mara for the woman she is instead of the wife she decides to be.  And yet, Maura is dedicated, as are all the characters in Searle’s book, to defending themselves and each other.  There is One, the Vietnamese maid and hostage, whose choppy bangs and large white teeth are the fond reminders that she will do anything to live in the land of the free; and Rakeen, Muslim “terrorist trick-or-treater” and “man of the house,” an innocent yet provocative threat, guardian, and dutiful brother and son.

Released this fall with New Rivers Press, Girl Held in Home is a close look at how affection is altered by expectation, by experience, and the absence of what we already know.  The book challenges us to be patient, just like its characters need patience to remove themselves from circumstance and imagine what, exactly, is going to happen next.  But, as I was reminded recently, isn’t developing patience the purpose of a great book?  If so, Searle has outdone herself.  My appreciation for Searle’s writing grows as the book “rat tats” onward, like the urgent pacing of Maura’s heels up the sidewalk, the swoosh of Sheila Jester’s boob job making headway across the PTA fundraiser gym floor, or the slicing of a sword into the basement air, gripped by a small, yet feisty, teenage boy.  Girl Held In Home is a brushstroke of cultural politics, and while I can’t always agree with Searle in tone or pitch,  it’s not Searle who I’m arguing with in my head.  Because after all, this is just fiction.

Josie E. Davis is the Managing Editor of PLOP!.  She is an artist and consultant based in Chicago, IL. Her most recent work can be viewed at Davis & Strathmann.com.

Girl Held in Home by Elizabeth Searle
Review by Josie E. Davis
Published by New Rivers Press, 2011
ISBN: 978-0-89823-258-5
228 Pages
Price: $10.17


4 thoughts on “Elizabeth Searle Unravels the Mystery of Terrorists and Teenagers in Suburban America

    • What a wonderful thought provoking, review of “Girl Held in Home” by Elizabeth Searle. I have my copy on order and am excited to read about this diverse cast of characters and what sounds like an outstanding plot. I have read all of her books, but this sounds like, for me, her best. I read the short story on which it is based and my enthusiasm for this writer was heightened by this review. I am an avid reader and this is the first time I have reached your website-you write a marvelous incisive review.

  1. WOW! What a Review! Elizabeth Searle has been reviewed with similar enthusiasm several times before and, what do you know, she always delivers! I’m not much of a reader but when I finally pick up her book, its hard to put down. Talent is a rare commodity indeed. She’s got it!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s